Preachers: Time to Ditch the Tie

by Sam Rainer | Jun 4, 2008 | Uncategorized | 14 comments

Without much regret I gave up wearing a tie while I preach several months ago. Hardly anyone in my church cared or noticed (with the exception of one anonymous hate letter in the offering plate).

After reading this article on the front page of the Wall Street Journal I now feel justified in my decision. Apparently after 60 years, the Men’s Dress Furnishings Association, the trade group that represents American tie makers, plans on shutting down operations on Thursday.

The article reports that a recent Gallup Poll revealed the number of men who wore ties every day to work last year dropped to a record low of 6%.

Perhaps this quote explains it all:

Some members of the neckwear association sensed the trend two years ago when, at the group’s annual luncheon in New York, a number of people turned up tieless.

While I realize a few contexts may still require some to continue wearing a tie, I think it’s time to put the paisley pinchers and skinny stranglers away.

But the bigger question remains – what to do about Father’s Day?

14 Comments

  1. Chuck Gaines

    I voted to go tieless about 5 years ago – kept only two: wedding & funeral tie. I’ll let my wife choose which one she buries me in. As for Father’s Day – I bet your dad is relieved!

    Reply
  2. Chuck Gaines

    I voted to go tieless about 5 years ago – kept only two: wedding & funeral tie. I’ll let my wife choose which one she buries me in. As for Father’s Day – I bet your dad is relieved!

    Reply
  3. Thom Rainer

    Send a card and/or money for Father’s Day. No tie.

    Reply
  4. Thom Rainer

    Send a card and/or money for Father’s Day. No tie.

    Reply
  5. Craig Webb

    Good call on the tie. I serve on a church staff where the younger staff do jeans and a t-shirt. I don’t believe I’ve ever seen my pastor, age 63, wearing a tie in the 5 years I’ve been there. A group of men recently chose to wear ties for Mother’s Day and it was awkward. My advice, don’t back slide on Father’s Day. Thanks for your good blog, Sam.

    Reply
  6. Craig Webb

    Good call on the tie. I serve on a church staff where the younger staff do jeans and a t-shirt. I don’t believe I’ve ever seen my pastor, age 63, wearing a tie in the 5 years I’ve been there. A group of men recently chose to wear ties for Mother’s Day and it was awkward. My advice, don’t back slide on Father’s Day. Thanks for your good blog, Sam.

    Reply
  7. Alvin Reid

    I speak at more youth events than church events. I am a much better preacher in a t shirt and jeans with a music stand for a pulpit. Still, I speak in a lot of venues and thus wear a tie when it is expected out of respect. I do not want to swing the pendulum to the place that frat boy style becomes en vogue for preachers!
    It was your dad who taught me the great rule of taking one blue blazer on trips and changing shirt and tie each day. Saved me a lot of money on suits over the years.
    One more thing: I recently read a comment by Finney that in his day there were churches whose tradition had it that a preacher wearing a tie was a liberal. Wow have we swung that pendulum the other way!

    Reply
  8. Alvin Reid

    I speak at more youth events than church events. I am a much better preacher in a t shirt and jeans with a music stand for a pulpit. Still, I speak in a lot of venues and thus wear a tie when it is expected out of respect. I do not want to swing the pendulum to the place that frat boy style becomes en vogue for preachers!
    It was your dad who taught me the great rule of taking one blue blazer on trips and changing shirt and tie each day. Saved me a lot of money on suits over the years.
    One more thing: I recently read a comment by Finney that in his day there were churches whose tradition had it that a preacher wearing a tie was a liberal. Wow have we swung that pendulum the other way!

    Reply
  9. Sam Rainer

    Dr. Reid – I dared my father to ditch the tie and become the first SBC agency head to present without one…he didn’t bite.

    Reply
  10. Sam Rainer

    Dr. Reid – I dared my father to ditch the tie and become the first SBC agency head to present without one…he didn’t bite.

    Reply
  11. Shane Vander Hart

    I rarely wear a tie. I don’t at the church where I am interim pastor, and the only time I have is when I’ve spoken or preached in churches where it is “the culture” of the church.

    Even in those churches only the minority of men were wearing ties… so I wonder why it is still considered “the culture”. Oh well.

    Having a rather thick neck I’m happy about the trend.

    Reply
  12. Shane Vander Hart

    I rarely wear a tie. I don’t at the church where I am interim pastor, and the only time I have is when I’ve spoken or preached in churches where it is “the culture” of the church.

    Even in those churches only the minority of men were wearing ties… so I wonder why it is still considered “the culture”. Oh well.

    Having a rather thick neck I’m happy about the trend.

    Reply
  13. Ahad Ghadimi

    Ties were good, but just like everything else, there time has come and gone. The problem is, it’s reached saturation – everybody and their dog (you know you’ve seen them) wear ties. People want to be unique – different. That’s why we see the huge return of the bow tie. I design and manufacture bow ties, so I naturally feel strongly about them. But if you (boy or girl or dog), can get over any preconceived notion about the classic neck accessory and wear it for a day – you’ll quickly feel the difference between a tie and a bow tie.

    Next up…the ascot!

    Reply
  14. Ahad Ghadimi

    Ties were good, but just like everything else, there time has come and gone. The problem is, it’s reached saturation – everybody and their dog (you know you’ve seen them) wear ties. People want to be unique – different. That’s why we see the huge return of the bow tie. I design and manufacture bow ties, so I naturally feel strongly about them. But if you (boy or girl or dog), can get over any preconceived notion about the classic neck accessory and wear it for a day – you’ll quickly feel the difference between a tie and a bow tie.

    Next up…the ascot!

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. I Want to Be an Old Man Some Day « Church Forward – […] Most older men dress classier. As many of you know, I’m not big on ties. But what happened to…
  2. I Want to Be an Old Man Some Day « Church Forward – […] Most older men dress classier. As many of you know, I’m not big on ties. But what happened to…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *