What Two Simple Statistics Reveal about the American Church

Church Stats

Sam Rainer

January 21, 2018


Statistics never tell the whole story, but they can validate a story exists. A chart detailing a decline in worship attendance cannot explain why the church is dying, but it does reveal the decline is actually occurring. During a recent church consultation, we interviewed a long-time member who refused to believe the church was declining. Even when we showed her a chart of their own numbers, she said, “You must have the wrong numbers.” If facts are our friends, then stats are our teachers. If we listen, we’ll learn.

Two simple statistics help explain the American church. There are other important church stats, but these two may surprise you.

  1. The median church size is 75 people.
  2. The median church age is 73 years.

Most American churches are smaller—under 100 people. Most American churches are older—existing for several decades. The story of the American church is one of small, established congregations.

First, a note about the term median: The median is a midpoint, not the average. If you want to make a statistician cringe, then say something like “The median average is . . .” Here is what we can learn from the above two stats. In the United States, half of the churches are younger than 73 years and half are older than 73 years. Half of the churches are smaller than 75 people and half are larger than 75 people.

Wait, isn’t much of the talk about younger megachurches? Yes, and I can understand why. They grew large in short amount of time. That’s worthy of a discussion.

What doesn’t get discussed as much is the segment of established churches that have under 100 people in average weekly worship attendance. They are the majority of churches in the United States!

Smaller churches are more normative than larger churches. Churches of 25, 50, and 100 are common. If you pastor such a church, you may feel abnormal because of the attention given to larger churches. However, it’s larger churches that are more the exception than the norm.

Established churches have one distinct advantage: Real estate. I’ve got lots of respect for the church planters setting up and tearing down every week in movie theaters and schools. Some pastors in established churches don’t know how good they have it. Sure, your roof leaks. I get how frustrating it can be. We have an old, tiny one-seater bathroom at our church. The light switch also turns on a fan that swirls so loudly the first time I went in there I thought the rapture was occurring. But we have a permanent location and an address everyone knows. Our real estate is a huge benefit to our ministry.

Small, established churches have a future. When I see a church on three acres buried in a dense neighborhood, I don’t think landlocked. I see an opportunity. Who else is better situated to reach the people there? These little churches dot the landscape of many cities. I realize many of them are dying and in desperate need of revitalization. But they have a future. Megachurches alone cannot return the American church to health. It’s going to take small, established churches too.

Two simple statistics reveal a lot about the American church. It’s smaller and established. If you belong to one, if you pastor one, then you are the future, not the past.


14 comments on “What Two Simple Statistics Reveal about the American Church”

  1. Roy Joyner says:

    In smaller churches people are a part of the hold. In mega churches few make the hold!

  2. Roberta Jones says:

    Those are great observations, and statistics to ponder. A small, thriving church blesses any community. Yet, so many stagnate and decline . . . held together by hopeful, praying, elderly men and women. In my home community, in southern Illinois, I’ve watched three small churches close. What early circuit riders started, changing times closed.

    1. Sam Rainer says:

      Those circuit riders were amazing testimonies of perseverance! We could use more like them today.

  3. Todd Burus says:

    I appreciate your post. Could you add a link to the research you are drawing these Statistics from? I am a college Statistics professor and think your analysis and data would be useful to share with my students.


  4. Ernie Zenone Sr. says:

    What about the lack of evangelizing by the average church members and by the elders? I see this missing in reformed churches. Why isn’t witnessing a priority, I mean public witnessing? If preaching is limited to in house preaching, how are those in the neighborhood to hear?

  5. Zach says:

    Fascinating. I noticed the link you provided cited a study done by the PC(USA). Was this sample taken primarily from that particular denomination or across American christendom?

  6. Quinton Everest says:

    Maybe I missed it, but I don’t see any documentation of your figures. The one about the median age is really hard to believe. Who came up with this figure?

    1. Sam Rainer says:

      It’s found here: https://www.amazon.com/Field-Guide-U-S-Congregations-Second/dp/066423514X

      I’ve seen the figure vary from 73 years to 84 years.

  7. John Worceste says:

    What is the average age of churches in USA?

    1. Sam Rainer says:

      I don’t have any data on average, just the median.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *